Saturday, 29 July 2017

Robespierre portraits - Some additions

PORTRAITS UNKNOWN TO BUFFENOIR

Watercolour by Moreau le Jeune, musée Lambinet

A striking image, and one which is familiar from the internet, but there seems to be no available documentation.  The illustrator and engraver Jean-Michel Moreau (1741-1814) was sympathetic to the Revolution.  He produced a famous engraving of the opening of the States-General in 1789 and a portrait of Charlotte Corday, also in the musée Lambinet.  This is surely the archetypal "cat-like look" Robespierre.

https://www.photo.rmn.fr/archive/09-518495-2C6NU097JQHU.html

Pastel attributed to Boze, Versailles, Musée national du château et des Trianons

45cm x 36,5 cm.  Sanguine, chalk and pastel on paper
http://collections.chateauversailles.fr/#d23f4e37-886d-49de-8f90-18767ddf60a6
The notice says only that the picture was the gift of M. de Knyff, in December 1952: date about 1794, "attributed to Boze"; but can all these disparate pictures really be by Boze?  I suppose the experts could tell if the picture were a fake, but it looks really modern to me!  M. de Knyff is probably the art historian Gilbert de Knyff.


Anonymous drawing of Robespierre from the Bibliothèque Nationale


Reproduced in David Jordan, Revolutionary career, plate VI. "A contemporary sketch of Robespierre at the tribune of the Convention.  The formality of his dress, including a wig, is apparent. The small, circumscribed gesture captured by the anonymous artist agress with the verbal descriptions of Robespierre's manner at the tribune.  His text...is an authentic detail, since he always spoke from a text."



I can't find the drawing on Gallica.  


I am just slightly worried by how close the pose is to this 19th -century engraving after Eugène Joseph Viollat (d.1901).





Portrait by the miniaturist Michel Thoüesny (1754-1815) 

Thoüesny painted Robespierre's portrait in 1791 whilst he lodged in the rue Saintonge. The painting has never been identified with certainty but of  interest is the revelation that Robespierre posed for itIn 1796 a certain citoyenne Naudet was interrogated and admitted to having known Robespierre: she testified "that her first husband, called Thoüesny, was a painter of miniatures and had painted Robespierre's portrait at the house of the commander of the batallion Enfans Rouge, in the rue de St.Onge (sic); that the citizen Robespierre had posed several times so that he could be painted from nature; that she believed that her husband had dined several times with the citizen Robespierre; that her husband had charged her with transporting the portrait to the rue Saint-Honoré to a carpenter's house where Robespierre then lived."

See: Michel Eude, "Robespierre et le miniaturiste Thoüesny" Annales historiques de la Révolution française (1955) 27/140 (1955), p.193-201 [on JStor] 


Drawing by Vivant Denon, sold by Christie's, Paris on 23 June 2009



http://www.christies.com/lotfinder/drawings-watercolors/dominique-vivant-denon-portrait-dun-jeune-homme-de-5220320-details.aspx



Vivant Denon, claimed spuriously that this Robespierre was "by David".   It seems unlikely that picture is drawn from life; but it is still worthy of note, since Vivant Denon had known Robespierre personally and was well acquainted with contemporary portraits.






PORTRAITS BELONGING TO FAMILY AND FRIENDS

These  images are in Buffenoir, but not catalogued by Thompson as they are derivative. 

Lithograph by Delpech


Buffenoir, vol.2(2), p. 55-6; Jordan, plate VIII, see p.254.  
Original lithograph by François Séraphin Delpech, one of a series of Revolutionary and Empire portraits produced in the 1820s. The print is best known in the version produced by Henri Grevedon.  Charlotte Robespierre thought it "one of the most lifelike" images of her brother.  It was probably the lithograph portrait mentioned in her death inventory in 1834.






Medallion modelled by Jacques-Auguste Collet in September 1791


Éléonore Duplay mentioned as a precious momento a plaster medallion modelled by Collet who was a designer for the Sèvres factory. Quite probably it once hung on the wall in the Duplay's salon. 


The medal was subject of a 19th-century print by Léopold Flameng.
.




5 comments:

  1. The chalk profile attributed to Boze is lovely, but I'm not sure it's Maximilien. The profile isn't quite… Well, there's a pertness to his profile which comes across in most portraits: the nose especially. I don't see it in this drawing. Is it an older man?

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Further thoughts: stylistically, the alleged Boze pastel profile reminds me of the Fouquet 'grand trait' of Max. I wonder if it's based on a physionotrace? The nose is a different shape to Max's, though.

    However, if it is him… Is it possible this could be the lost Labille-Guiard?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for all the comments. Yes, you are right - this picture really doesn't ring true. I wonder if there is any more info. to be had?

      Delete
  4. Since I've managed to get another academic admin job I have JSTOR access again, so managed to get the Buffenoir text in chunks, as you did. I'm going through his plates (from that online resource). I don't think that pastel is one he knows.

    The profile is not Max's: he has a very pert, slightly retroussé nose. Also, the wig with the double row of curls isn't one he wears in any other portrait: he sticks with the single rolled curl all the way around, including when his hair is loose at the back.

    The size is similar to the Fouquet 'grand trait' and the style is very similar (the way the wig/hair and coat are drawn). Whether it's by Fouquet or not, it has the look of a physionotrace 'grand trait' (the pose, the scale, the attention paid to the eyes) that's been worked up with pastel. The more I look at it, the more I think "physionotrace" and "not Max".

    Here's Max in a similar outfit and similar hairstyle (but with single roll), again probably originally from a physionotrace:
    https://78.media.tumblr.com/efbe669ad7862d5410ca53be6aabb5df/tumblr_inline_p3klr8w1qG1v3qujz_1280.jpg
    The shapes of the jaw, chin and nose are completely different.

    ReplyDelete