Sunday, 1 December 2024

Lunéville - dreams of Nature


The following is (mostly) taken from a talk in the "Wednesday Lecture" series, given at Lunéville in May of this year by the director of the Musée du Château, Thierry Franz.   His  subject is embrace of "Nature" in the Court culture of 18th-century Lorraine, with particular reference to the lost ménageries at Lunéville and the country château of La Malgrange, which have recently been brought to life in virtual reconstructions.   Rather than through ceremonial or lavish display, Thierry Franz argues, it was by their openness to nature that the Dukes of Lorraine showed themselves to be at the forefront of European élite culture.   

The lecture focuses particularly on the contribution of the Duchess Élisabeth-Charlotte, who in 1700 chose to have herself depicted as Flora, the Roman goddess of gardens and flowers:

 Portrait of the Duchess Élisabeth-Charlotte as Flora, c. 1700. Attributed to Claude Charles (1661-1747), "premier peintre" of the Court of Lorraine.  Musée du Château de Lunéville.

During her childhood at Versailles and Saint-Cloud, Élisabeth-Charlotte had acquired a taste for open-air pursuits. Like Duke Leopold, who was a keen huntsman and breeder of horses, she was an accomplished horsewoman.  According to contemporaries, in her younger years she loved to ride at a gallop. The daily chronicles and archives of the palace are full of hunts and horse rides, but also of picnics in the woods - open air meals were very fashionable in general in the 18th century, but found particular favour with the ducal couple.

Attributed to Jean-Baptiste Martin, Equestrian portrait of the Duchess of Lorraine,
  Hofburg, Insbruck (Wikimedia)  The pendant is a similar depiction of Leopold.

The Duke and Duchess's preference for the countryside was also reflected in their building programme.  They favoured country residences:  Lunéville itself , "un palais aux champs"and, above all,  Einville, the ancient ducal domain situated about eight kilometres to the north, in the valley of the river Sanon.  It was here that the couple retired  for the belle saison, surrounded by a select court.  Beginning in 1701, the old château was progressively demolished and replaced by a modest residence. In 1704, a  second phase of reconstruction saw the addition of  new wings and two courtyards which preceded the corps de logis. In 1711 Boffrand also began work at La Malgrange, the small ducal estate just outside the gates of Nancy, which Leopold and Élisabeth-Charlotte appreciated for its clean air and waters, and for its views over the countryside.


THE MENAGERIES

 The  construction of "ménageries",   small lodges or pleasure farms, on the outskirts of the official ducal residences,  afforded  spaces where "the exercise of country pursuits combined a certain philosophical vision with the enjoyment of  everyday pleasures".


The ménagerie at La Malgrange

At La Malgrange, a ménagerie of sorts - a working garden or small farm rather than a "zoo" -  had existed since the early 17th century when a small pavilion next to the old château  had been given over to Catherine de Bourbon - wife of Duke Henry II and sister to Henri IV of France - and turned into a little agricultural domain with a few exotic animals.  Élisabeth-Charlotte began renovations here as early a 1699.

Jacques Callot, The old castle or Ménagerie at La Malgrange, c. 1700.
Devonshire Collection, Chatworth (on Bridgeman Art etc.)

Thierry Franz emphasises that the Duchess was personally involved in the project.  She already knew Boffrand, who had completed work for the Orléans family in Paris before being named as Leopold's premier architect in 1711.  Moreover, she would have had in mind a particular model, that of the Ménagerie at Versailles, which in May 1698 had been given over by Louis XIV to her relative and friend,  Marie-Adélaïde of Savoy, the Duchess of Burgundy.

The original purpose of the pavilion in Versailles, built in the 1660s, had been to house exotic animals,  but its location, at the south extremity of the Grand Canal directly opposite the Trianon, made it a pleasant retreat for royal parties, who could be rowed there by gondola.  The young Duchess had been very pleased to be offered the little château, which she had been busy renovating at the time of Élisabeth-Charlotte's marriage.

It seems that  Louis XIV had originally intended to repeat his generous gesture by paying for the work at La Malgrange.  During his brief stay in Lorraine in 1700 Mansard drew up the plans;  surviving drawings show annotations, probably in the Duchess's own hand. In the event, under the direction of Pierre Bourdict, the existing structure was retained but  extensively modernised. The result exemplified the height of fashionable French style.  The unpretentious classical exterior concealed an "absolutely extraordinary" interior echoing the pavilion at Versailles, with large mirrors over the mantle-pieces and sets of small pictures arranged around the walls. 

From the 3D reconstruction of the Versailles menagerie by Hubert Naudeix (2007) - on YouTube.   
A second reconstruction, created this year as part of the VERSPERA project at Versailles, shows clearly the arrangement of mirrors.

In the domain Élisabeth-Charlotte resumed agricultural production, with cattle and a courtyard for hens and rare breeds:  Polish and Egyptian pigeons, for example, were bought at great expense from a dealer in Waterloo.  She herself would work in the dairy, reflecting the fashion of the time for gifts of one's own making like jam, cheese and butter. 

In 1711 Leopold began construction of  a new château at La Malgrange but after 1715 the palace was seldom used and the menagerie neglected.  Under King Stanislas it became the property of his mistress,  the marquise de Boufflers.  

Plan of the old château and Ménagerie at La Malgrange in 1714-15.[On Gallica]


The Ménagerie at Lunéville 

At the Palace of Lunéville itself the Duchess is known to have kept a kitchen garden from as early as 1700.  It occupied a narrow space, ten metres or so wide, on the site of the present chapel, adjacent to  Élisabeth-Charlotte's private apartments.  Here she could personally supervise the cultivation of cabbages, asparagus, melons and strawberries. She also kept chickens. Elisabeth-Charlotte  was a pioneer of cooking as an aristocratic pastime, a fashion which developed in France from about 1750.  In 1707 a small pavilion was constructed at one end which contained a little kitchen and a private dining room.

Reconstruction of the jardin potager by Vincent Hertz
Still from the 2017  video "Métamorphoses:  Le chantier du chateau de Lunéville en images, 1698-1737".  Available on YouTube.


In 1712, when this initial refuge was destroyed by the construction of the new South Wing,  Leopold,"who sought his wife's forgiveness for his various sins", presented her with a new ménagerie, in the faubourgs. This new retreat was also known as "les confitures de la duchesse", since it was here that she prepared her jams and conserves.

Approximate site of the Lunéville ménagerie 

The property, which had formerly belonged to Leopold's Court physician  Jean-Baptiste Alliot, occupied a site to the south-west of the Château near the Porte Jolie, bounded by the rue de la République and the rue Banaudon / rue Cyfflé.  It would have been easily accessible on foot or by sedan chair.   

Thierry Franz 's initial archival research formed the basis for a virtual reconstruction by the graphic artist Vincent Hertz.  The resulting video was made available to visitors to the Château; it doesn't seem to be accessible on the internet, though the lecture includes some stills (see below). 

 The main house which served as the pavilion, had been constructed in 1705 directly into the former defensive walls of the medieval town.  It remained little altered apart from the addition of a kitchen with blue-and-white Delft tiles.  To the front was an ornamental parterre with a central fountain.  In the basse-cour she kept animals: six small pavilions or lodges, which housed mainly exotic fowl, but also tortoises which were brought to Lunéville at great expense.

In the grounds were grown all sorts of fruit and vegetables for the ducal table - cabbages, asparagus, melons, strawberries and, after an extensive search for seeds, the rare treat of broccoli.  To one side, against the old city wall, Élisabeth-Charlotte had a heated greenhouse installed.  


In 1719 the domain was extended to include an orchard, with no less than 400 palisaded fruit-trees,  mostly apples or pears, but also apricots, peaches and several varieties of plum. There was also a vineyard under the expert supervision of a winegrower from Champagne. The Duchess reported her grape harvest with pleasure and had a press imported for wine production.  Further building in 1730 created a small working farm where and her friends could taste milk from her cows, and make butter and cheese, far from the Court.   

Though primarily a retreat, the Ménagerie was also a site for entertainments.  A rare engraving in the Musée Lorrain shows the firework display put on in May 1713 for the visit by James Stuart,  Chevalier de Saint-Georges,  the pretender to the English throne.


Today, sadly, nothing remains of the Lunéville ménagerie,  apart from an isolated pillar which formed part of the entrance in the rue des Remparts:

Pillar  at 23 Rue du Rempart, the last vestige of the Lunéville Ménagerie - on Google maps (love me, love my wheelie-bins!) 

It seems that the intention was was to incorporate a ménagerie in each of the ducal properties: in a painting of Einville from 1750 (lost in the 2003 fire) can be seen a dovecote, belonging to a ménagerie built by Élisabeth-Charlotte and Francis III in 1730. 

Detail of canvas destroyed in 2003 (L'Est Républicain)


In her final years of exile, Élisabeth-Charlotte was able to recapture something of her earlier pleasures due to the existence of  a ménagerie at Commercy, which had originally been built in the 17th century as summer residence of the Cardinal de Retz. Today the vestiges of this domain form part of the mairie in the little town of Ville-Issey, to the south-east of Commercy:  the wing to the right of the picture corresponds to the original ménagerie.  

The mairie at Ville-Issey (Wikipedia)



THE DUCHESS ÉLISABETH-CHARLOTTE'S GARDEN

The idea of closeness to nature is apparent also, more generally, in the design of the royal residences themselves.  Even before the Château at Lunéville became the official seat of power,  the Court had  intended to spend the belle saison there.  The royal apartments were sited to overlook the Park and its parterres.  For Élisabeth-Charlotte this affinity dated back to her childhood in Versailles when she would often visit the domain of the Trianon with her mother, from whom she inherited her taste for nature: the letters of the Princess Palatine tell us that at the Trianon  the branches of the trees almost entered her apartments. 

At Lunéville, when the new South Wing was built in 1715, an area along the south fringe of the Park, immediately adjacent to the Hôtel Craon, was reserved for the Duchess's private parterres, which were shielded from public view by a honeysuckle-covered trellis.  There was no longer question of a "jardin potager" - this was a purely ornamental flower garden, taking its inspiration from the jardin du Roi at the Grand Trianon. 

In 2009  archaeological investigation uncovered traces of the landscaping.  Remnants were found of the central fountain which was on the exact axis of  Élisabeth-Charlotte's private apartments, so as to be  visible from her chamber.  Outside her windows, she could enjoy the scent of tuberoses and other flowers chosen for their fragrance. (She had hoped to plant orange trees, but was thwarted by the severe winter weather: a portable cloche was installed in the Autumn of 1724 to protect them, but there are no further references in the archives. )

Still from  the 2017 video "Métamorphoses:  Le chantier du chateau de Lunéville en images, 1698-1737".  Available on YouTube.


In 2019 a project was undertaken to reconstruct the Duchess's garden using, as far as possible, authentic plants and methods of cultivation: it was opened officially on 9th June 2019:


Photos from L'Est Républicain, 09.06.2019


From the information panels:

Panel One

"Following the fire of January 2003, archaeological investigations were conducted to gain a better understanding of the history and evolution of the park, seconded by significant archival research. Twenty-four test pits were dug across the gardens between October and December 2009,  which uncovered traces of the canal, its banks and several fountains.  At the foot of the small wing of the Château were discovered vestiges of  a small circular water feature which would have been directly visible from the Duchess's private apartments.

The private parterre of the Duchess Élisabeth-Charlotte  was designed at the beginning of 2019 by a team of the Château's gardeners.  They took their inspiration from the archives and plans of the era, but the project was also a practical experiment, using 18th-century methods of planting. Flowers were more spaced out  to allow them to be fully appreciated.  The association of annuals and perennials; and the presence of shrubs also conforms to the practice of the time.  As today, the soil was covered with a mulch to conserve moisture and reduce the need for watering.  The threat of diseases and parasites was combated by the use of hardy shrubs such as Ilex crenata (Japanese holly)"


 Panel Two

Élisabeth-Charlotte's secret garden

"... The work of transforming the park was entrusted by Leopold to Yves Deszours, "dessinateur et directeur des jardins". Work on the terraces began in 1707 and in 1712 the "Parc des Bosquets" was laid out on its  present plan. Imposing parterres occupied the central perspective,  bordered by trees and shrubs.

Leopold gave the inhabitants of Lunéville the right to enter the new gardens, but he reserved for his wife the band of ground which bordered the town to the south.  Here the Duchess Élisabeth-Charlotte supervised the construction of a series of small parterres, punctuated by fountains.  These formed what is described in the archives as "the flower garden of her Highness Madame Royale", accessible by a flight of steps from the private ducal apartments.  In this retreat, hidden from the world by a enclosing trellis, the Duchess cultivated rare blooms.  She recreated the intimate atmosphere of the private gardens of the Sun King at the Grand Trianon  After 1737 the new duke, Stanislas Leszczynski remodelled the parterres in what now became "les petits bosquets".  All trace of the trellises and fountains disappeared after his death in 1766. In the 19th century, a wall was constructed, leaving a only an area of lawn the foot of the Château.  A recently discovered plan from around 1720 enables us to re-imagine this refuge in nature which Élizabeth-Charlotte so loved."

Plan of the Château c.1720, showing details of the Duchess's private parterre (in green). Bibl.de Nancy, fonds Piroux.


THE DUCHESS'S CHILDREN

Overlooking these gardens, were the family's private apartments. That of Francis III,  with its "chambre verte", was created in 1729.  Francis too had a passionate for nature.  The French emissary d'Audiffret complained that on one occasion Francis deliberately missed their dinner engagement, preferring to dine alone in the his mother's ménagerie. 

The "chambre verte" had cages reserved for his canaries, whose droppings spoilt the beautiful green lacquer work.

Pierre Gobert, Francis of Lorraine in 1713. Musée du Château de Lunéville 

The portrait above, acquired in 2017, shows the infant Francis with a puppy and a monkey. These  animals were not just imaginary accessories.   Dogs and monkeys were kept in the royal apartments as domestic pets, as were quails, and ferrets (safely in different quarters, one hopes!).  A room directly below the chambre verte, so actually in the interior of the palace,  was reserved for fancy poultry.  In later life, as Emperor, Francis continued to keep animals and develop his interest in botany.  

Franz Walter, Charles-Alexander of Lorraine and his sister,c.1770
Ink drawing. Bildarchive der Österreichischen Nationalbibliothek. 
Image from
Au temps de Marie Antoinette Facebook page  (where it is said to show
 Francis of Lorraine and the Empress Maria-Theresa).

Another illustrative portrait shows Francis's younger brother Charles-Alexander and his sister Anne-Charlotte (Lolotte) in a garden in about 1770. The flowers are not just a trope. As a young prince Charles-Alexander had a balcony overlooking the garden where he cultivated flowers; archival records mention his silver-handled gardening tools.  The ideals of closeness to nature are exemplified in Charles-Alexander's  "Petit Château"/"Château de la Favorite" built at the edge of Les Bosquets in the early 1730s, with gardens designed by Yves Deszours and its own small menagerie. 

The Court followed the lead of their ruling family.  The town houses in Nancy and Lunéville were relatively modest, but small country retreats were fashionable.  The outstanding example is the maison de plaisance of the Prince and Princess de Beauvau-Craon in the suburb of Mesnil, close to the River Meurthe, which still survives in part in the grounds of the Lycée Saint-Pierre Fourier.




THE MÉNAGERIES OF KING STANISLAS

Stanislas Leszczyński,  who became Duke of Lorraine in 1737, continued the preference for closeness to nature and added his own architectural inheritance.  His  pleasure pavilions and elaborate Rococo gardens reached new heights of fantasy (for a different post, I think!)   Two sites were, however,  specifically characterised as "ménageries".  

Charles Bour, The domaine de l'Oasis, 1861. Musée du Château de Lunéville

The first was the little estate constructed for the Duke and Duchess Ossolinski in about 1741. The house, which still survives today, is  "L'Oasis", on the Avenue du Dr Paul Kahn near the Lycée Ernest Bichat.  The painting, above, by the Lunéville artist Charles Bour, who lived there in the 1860s., shows that the exterior was originally quite rustic in appearance, though the interior would have been more elaborate.  
The property was sold in 2015 and now a smart reception/conference centre.



L'Oasis - website
Pascale Debert, "La maison du duc Ossolinsky", Couleur XVIIIe, post of 10.09.2015.
 
The Château de Jolivet a manor house about two kilometres north of Lunéville, was acquired by  Stanislas in 1740.  This little country retreat was often known as the "Ménagerie de Stanislas"; a painting by Jolivet, shows the balconies with their planters and a small aviary.  Sadly, this building has now entirely disappeared. 



References

CONFÉRENCE / LES VENDREDIS DU MUSÉE:  Thierry Franz, "Les ménageries, refuges champêtres aux portes des palais de Lorraine", 6th February 2023 [VIDEO]


VIRTUAL RECONSTRUCTIONS:
  "Métamorphoses:  Le chantier du chateau de Lunéville en images, 1698-1737"(2017).  by Vincent Hertz , posted on YouTube 06.02.2023.
"La Chambre verte de François III", 7th March 2023 


ÉLISABETH-CHARLOTTE'S PRIVATE GARDEN
"Lunéville : le parterre de la Duchesse officiellement ouvert dans le parc du château de Lunéville"
L'Est Républicain, 09.06.2019

"Restitution du jardin privé d'Elisabeth-Charlotte d'Orléans à Lunéville".  Discussion on the Forum Marie-Antoinette 
https://marie-antoinette.forumactif.org/t4711-restitution-du-jardin-prive-d-elisabeth-charlotte-d-orleans-a-luneville

No comments:

Post a Comment

Print Friendly and PDF